|
Post by galvatron prime on May 7, 2019 1:48:29 GMT
siuyiu Admin anyone Is Aqing The Best and number 1 Fighter In Jinyong Universe? Could Aqing From Sword Of The Yue Maiden Easily Defeat Dugu Qiubai One On One? What About Chan Kan Nam? My Clients said Chan is number one and he the founder of Chinese Gangster and Taikor. Chan Kan Nam In the Duke Of Mount Deer in 2000 started By Ekin Cheng could even defeat the Qing Soldier which have Canon and Gun. Could Aqing Defeat Qing Army who have Canon and Gun.
|
|
|
Post by Admin on May 7, 2019 3:12:00 GMT
Could Aqing From Sword Of The Yue Maiden Easily Defeat Dugu Qiubai One On One? : My personal believe is yes. Because Aqing swordsmanship is based on natural defense and attack, it was an ape who taught her, so basically all her movements probably are based on survival instinct. I think she could defeat Dugu Qiubai. What About Chan Kan Nam? My Clients said Chan is number one and he the founder of Chinese Gangster and Taikor.Chan Kan Nam In the Duke Of Mount Deer in 2000 started By Ekin Cheng could even defeat the Qing Soldier which have Canon and Gun. Chan Kan Nam should be Chen Jin Nan the leader of Heaven and Earth Society? I tend to believe on the theory that martial arts and swordsmanship are on it's peak on Song Dynasty, and decline afterward. Therefore I think Aqing might be better than Chen Jinnan and she should be able to defeat Chen Jinnan one on one easily. But for Aqing to defeat Qing Army who have canon and gun would not be easy. She's just a naive girl who knew how to fight based on instinct. While to fight an army with guns and canons also need tactics and strategies. That's my two cents.
|
|
|
Post by siuyiu on May 7, 2019 3:15:57 GMT
i haven't read sword of the yue maiden, so i'm in no position to comment! interesting theory, though!
|
|
|
Post by atumiwa on May 7, 2019 4:20:07 GMT
i dont know, lack of data to compare them.
in interview, Jin Yong only said Dugu's name when someone ask who is the strongest in his universe.
but Yue maiden did some amazing stuff like God-Speed offensive attack (it was said that there were total 2000 elite soldiers outside, not long after Fan Ling hear the dropped of weapons, a green shadow already appear in front of him, so that make Ah Qing a super duper fast monster)
|
|
ari
New Member
Posts: 1
|
Post by ari on Apr 30, 2021 15:41:58 GMT
For me with a lack of data to compare, A Qing can't defeat Dugu Qiu Bai, fighting against a soldier is of course different from the technique of fighting against the superb swordman
|
|
|
Post by machete on May 8, 2021 15:05:44 GMT
No. Her skill is majority made up of human capability only. The dynasty era which she is set in didn't have any of those high internal skills. DGQB was from an era with those supernatural internal skills. Besides,his Dugu 9 sword is made up of various moves in the Sword Breaking Stance which are especially meant to counter various other sword moves which have already evolved very highly ever since Ah Qing's time.
If Jin Yong really follows history then Chan Kan Nam could not have been the one who started the Triads. During the Qing dynasty the Triads weren't even gangsters yet.The Chan Kan Nam in the DOMD 2000 is waaay too superhuman. In the original novel,he is nothing like that.
Ah Qing cannot do that and neither can Chan Kan Nam.
|
|
|
Post by machete on May 8, 2021 15:25:07 GMT
I tend to believe on the theory that martial arts and swordsmanship are on it's peak on Song Dynasty, and decline afterward. Therefore I think Aqing might be better than Chen Jinnan and she should be able to defeat Chen Jinnan one on one easily. I tend to believe that in Yue Maidens Sword's time (Ah Qing's era which was the Spring and Autumn period (771 to 476 BC)the skills involving internal energy hadn't existed yet. The era where the supernatural internal skills first showed up was either Tang or Demi God Semi Devils time in early Sung. Chen Jin Nan has internal power skills but Aobai was believed to be his equal despite not having internal skills. So probably Ah Qing could beat him unless his more evolved and more complex sword skills could overwhelm her. That being said,his internal skills has no chance against Ah Qing despite she not having any internal skills. Confused yet?Even I am getting confused.
|
|
|
Post by Admin on Jun 3, 2021 4:59:22 GMT
I tend to believe on the theory that martial arts and swordsmanship are on it's peak on Song Dynasty, and decline afterward. Therefore I think Aqing might be better than Chen Jinnan and she should be able to defeat Chen Jinnan one on one easily. I tend to believe that in Yue Maidens Sword's time (Ah Qing's era which was the Spring and Autumn period (771 to 476 BC)the skills involving internal energy hadn't existed yet. The era where the supernatural internal skills first showed up was either Tang or Demi God Semi Devils time in early Sung. Chen Jin Nan has internal power skills but Aobai was believed to be his equal despite not having internal skills. So probably Ah Qing could beat him unless his more evolved and more complex sword skills could overwhelm her. That being said,his internal skills has no chance against Ah Qing despite she not having any internal skills. Confused yet?Even I am getting confused. I personally also believe that internal energy had not developed during the Spring and Autumn Era. But the short story created by JY - The Sword of Yue Maiden mentioned that AQing had a very strong internal energy that when she raised her bamboo stick, her internal energy penetrated Xi Shi's chest and hurt her. Since we're talking about Jin Yong's universe, so we have to assume that Aqing had an internal energy
|
|
|
Post by machete on Jun 6, 2021 7:44:45 GMT
I tend to believe that in Yue Maidens Sword's time (Ah Qing's era which was the Spring and Autumn period (771 to 476 BC)the skills involving internal energy hadn't existed yet. The era where the supernatural internal skills first showed up was either Tang or Demi God Semi Devils time in early Sung. Chen Jin Nan has internal power skills but Aobai was believed to be his equal despite not having internal skills. So probably Ah Qing could beat him unless his more evolved and more complex sword skills could overwhelm her. That being said,his internal skills has no chance against Ah Qing despite she not having any internal skills. Confused yet?Even I am getting confused. I personally also believe that internal energy had not developed during the Spring and Autumn Era. But the short story created by JY - The Sword of Yue Maiden mentioned that AQing had a very strong internal energy that when she raised her bamboo stick, her internal energy penetrated Xi Shi's chest and hurt her. Since we're talking about Jin Yong's universe, so we have to assume that Aqing had an internal energy Maybe the Chinese version you read mentioned that A Qing had a lot of internal energy but the English version only says that there was chi coming out the bamboo stick but did not say that A Qing had very strong internal energy.
Before he even finished the word, “here”, the curtain parted and a green shadow came flying in. A’qing, dressed in her usual green stood before them. She pointed her bamboo stick at Xi Shi. She stared at the face of Xi Shi, the killing rage on face gradually disappeared, replaced with disappointment and self-pity, then it changed to surprise, admiration and finally worship. She whispered, “There… there really is such beauty under heaven! Fan Li, she is even more… more beautiful than you described.” Her slender waist turned. With a cry, she flew up through the window. The cry went farther and farther until its reverberation was left.
The surviving guards ran inside the room. One of them bowed, “Minister, are you all right?” Fan Li merely dismissed them with a wave of his hand. Then he held Xi Shi’s hand and said, “Let’s change into the clothes of commoners. We’ll go rowing a boat upon Lake Tai and never return to this place.”
Happiness shone from Xi Shi’s eyes. Suddenly she frowned and she reached toward her heart. A’qing’s bamboo stick didn’t touch her, but the pure chi from the stick had reached into her body and did her some slight harm.
In the next two thousand years, all people know that the most beautiful image in the world was Xi Shi holding her hands in front of her bosom.
|
|
|
Post by machete on Mar 21, 2023 10:14:08 GMT
Admin I think this wikipedia article is something you might like. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yuenü .I just discovered this story two days ago. This is the original story of the Yue maiden. But Jin Yong tried to make his own version more realistic by putting a real ape into his story instead of an old man transforming into an ape.
|
|