|
Post by Admin on Sept 16, 2019 3:06:02 GMT
siuyiuI remember you pick Yeung Chak Lam as Best Au Yeung Fung ,am I right on this? Which version do you think he play better as Au Yeung Fung,1976 or 1983 version? Yeung Chak Lam is a good actor. I wonder if he's still alive now. He's really a good Awyang Feng. He's also good as the antagonist at the Taichi Master
|
|
|
Post by siuyiu on Sept 16, 2019 23:30:17 GMT
siuyiu I remember you pick Yeung Chak Lam as Best Au Yeung Fung ,am I right on this? Which version do you think he play better as Au Yeung Fung,1976 or 1983 version? yes, you are! i've never watched him in the 1976 version, so i can't comment. i'm assuming, since he'd've been a few years older in the 1983 version, that he looked more convincing as an older man.
|
|
|
Post by galvatron prime on Sept 28, 2019 14:53:27 GMT
各版張翠山:埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】
|
|
|
Post by galvatron prime on Sept 28, 2019 14:56:56 GMT
siuyiuI remember you pick Damian Lau as Best Cheung Chui San,am I right on this? Admin
|
|
|
Post by siuyiu on Sept 28, 2019 16:10:11 GMT
siuyiu I remember you pick Damian Lau as Best Cheung Chui San,am I right on this? Admin yep! though simon yam comes a very close second. do-do, on the other hand...
|
|
|
Post by galvatron prime on Dec 11, 2019 2:28:08 GMT
各版鵰兄:埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】
各版公孫綠萼:埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】
各版岳靈珊,埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】
各版洪七公,埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】
|
|
|
Post by galvatron prime on Dec 11, 2019 2:41:35 GMT
siuyiu I remember you pick Lau Dan as the best Hung Chat Gong,am I right. siuyiu Admin Do the Giants Condor really cannot fly in the novel? Do you think The Giants Condors actually feather Dinosaur not Condor?
|
|
|
Post by siuyiu on Dec 11, 2019 3:45:31 GMT
wow, she's still at it with the comparisons? what is she going to do when she runs out of characters? @galvatron correct about my pick. gosh, it's been so long since i read the books--i don't remember if the condor could fly or not. but scientists who study fossils are very certain that birds are descended from dinosaurs, so yes, the giant condor is a feathered dinosaur descendant. whether it's more t-rex than pterodactyl is up for debate.
|
|
|
Post by Admin on Dec 11, 2019 7:20:09 GMT
siuyiu I remember you pick Lau Dan as the best Hung Chat Gong,am I right. siuyiu Admin Do the Giants Condor really cannot fly in the novel? Do you think The Giants Condors actually feather Dinosaur not Condor? LOL. I don't think giant condor could fly.In the novel, YG tried to commit suicide by jumping off the cliff, and GX followed him and also jumped. GX's condor then went to the bottom of the valley to save them. GX was managed to be saved, by flying with one of the condor. Meanwhile, the couple of the condor, was killed by Golden Wheel Monk and died. Therefore, the other condor, heartbroken and bumped its own head onto a big rock and died. Therefore YG was left behind. The giant condor, if it could fly, then YG wouldn't have to rely on GX's condors. The Giants Condor actually feather Dinosaur or a Condor? Hmm...feathered dinosaur is possible. Or a mutant gorilla with big arms that looked like wings but actually hands? Apparently, ancient China had rhinoceros, and also Palaeoloxodon. Therefore the chance for the Giant Condor to be a dinosaur or other exotic animal is very possible.
|
|
|
Post by reinafu on Dec 13, 2019 11:32:19 GMT
galvatron prime, this is an interesting thread, but unfortunately, the characters' names are written in Chinese only, so, I don't know which characters you are talking about in your different posts. In your post on september 28th, I recognize Cheung Ying, Chang Yi, Ha Yu, Yueh Hua and Damian Lau but I don't know which character they play, and they all played in so many wuxia, that it's difficult to guess who they play by just looking at the pictures. And in the last clip you posted, I recognize Ku Feng, Lau Dan and Beardy, but once again, playing who ?
So, if I'm not too demanding in your opinion, could you mention the Mandarin names of the characters played in your future comparison clips, please ?
Thanks a lot in advance.
|
|
|
Post by galvatron prime on Dec 17, 2019 10:19:45 GMT
galvatron prime , this is an interesting thread, but unfortunately, the characters' names are written in Chinese only, so, I don't know which characters you are talking about in your different posts. In your post on september 28th, I recognize Cheung Ying, Chang Yi, Ha Yu, Yueh Hua and Damian Lau but I don't know which character they play, and they all played in so many wuxia, that it's difficult to guess who they play by just looking at the pictures. And in the last clip you posted, I recognize Ku Feng, Lau Dan and Beardy, but once again, playing who ?
So, if I'm not too demanding in your opinion, could you mention the Mandarin names of the characters played in your future comparison clips, please ?
Thanks a lot in advance.
reinafu Sorry ,I Don't Understand Mandarin. My Mandarin is very weak. I only know Cantonese name of each character You Don't Understand Cantonese?
|
|
|
Post by reinafu on Dec 17, 2019 12:27:45 GMT
galvatron prime , this is an interesting thread, but unfortunately, the characters' names are written in Chinese only, so, I don't know which characters you are talking about in your different posts. In your post on september 28th, I recognize Cheung Ying, Chang Yi, Ha Yu, Yueh Hua and Damian Lau but I don't know which character they play, and they all played in so many wuxia, that it's difficult to guess who they play by just looking at the pictures. And in the last clip you posted, I recognize Ku Feng, Lau Dan and Beardy, but once again, playing who ?
So, if I'm not too demanding in your opinion, could you mention the Mandarin names of the characters played in your future comparison clips, please ?
Thanks a lot in advance.
reinafu Sorry ,I Don't Understand Mandarin. My Mandarin is very weak. I only know Cantonese name of each character You Don't Understand Cantonese? No need to apologize, of course. I don't understand Cantonese, but if you can name the characters by their cantonese name, it will do, thank you very much.
|
|
|
Post by galvatron prime on Dec 29, 2019 2:15:31 GMT
各版王重陽,埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】
|
|
|
Post by galvatron prime on Dec 29, 2019 2:21:00 GMT
siuyiuI think Lee Lung Kei From ROCH 1983 your ,best favourites Wong Chung Yeung,am I right on this ? If not who is the best? My pick is Ekin Cheng. Admin
|
|
|
Post by siuyiu on Dec 29, 2019 4:55:54 GMT
@galvatron i haven't seen all the adaptations, but based on acting abilities, i would pick kong hon as the best to portray a middle-aged/elderly wong chung yeung. the two young mainland actors who portray young WCY are definitely pretty--can they act, though?
|
|