|
Post by galvatron prime on May 13, 2019 2:58:09 GMT
Hello,I have a Question? How Did Guo Jing And his family get killed in Battle Of Xianyang since it Kung Fu are superior To Mongol Army ? Did they get killed by hired killer whose Kung Fu are more stronger than Dugu Qiubai or Ahqing ? Or Betray by Yelu Qi his son in law by poison the food and water as advise by Kublai Khan? Why Yang Guo and Little Dragon girls not helping them defending Xiangyang? Why Yang Guo done nothing ? If Yang Guo Feature In Battle Of Xiayang,Will Guo Jing And Huang Rong be saved? Is Wong Yat Shi,Chow Bat Tung,Ying Gu and South Emperor Duang Chi Hing get killed as well. siuyiu Admin anyone
|
|
|
Post by siuyiu on May 13, 2019 3:53:08 GMT
sorry, don't know the answer--i've never read HSDS cover-to-cover. i would assume that, after they reunited, YG and XLN mutually agreed to withdraw from the world and spend their remaining days doing whatever the hell they felt like doing. so, presuming that, they wouldn't care about the fate of xiangyang. it would be unfortunate if YLQ ended up turning traitor, given that he basically turned his back on his family and the mongols in order to marry GF. after opening fighting against the mongols during the attempt to rescue GX, it'd be hard for him to re-gain their trust, even if he were a spy for them from the get-go.
|
|
|
Post by Admin on May 13, 2019 4:14:37 GMT
How Did Guo Jing And his family get killed in Battle Of Xianyang since it Kung Fu are superior To Mongol Army ? Did they get killed by hired killer whose Kung Fu are more stronger than Dugu Qiubai or Ahqing ? ---> it was a great battle and they just couldn't simply win against the massive Mongolian army. They might have a great martial art skills, but who could resist thousands of rain arrows? Or Betray by Yelu Qi his son in law by poison the food and water as advise by Kublai Khan? --> Yelu Qi was a Khitan, and he had enmity against the Jin (Jurchen). But he had no strong tie to Mongolian. He's probably had stronger tie to Song as his wife, parents in law, and even martial art teacher were Song. Why Yang Guo and Little Dragon girls not helping them defending Xiangyang? ---> YG and XLN, both of them never had interest in defending their country. During the 16 years of waiting for XLN, YG was just 'killing time', and that's how he roamed in jianghu and helped many people who were oppressed by Mongolian. But he himself never had any sense of patriotism. The part when the Mongolian with Golden Wheel Monk tried to challenge the martial artists from Zhongyuan, Yang Guo was totally not interested. Then he met XLN, and the novel said, the two of them just moved to the corner and chatted and ignored everything. But then something happened and they were disturbed, therefore YG got really angry and fought them. So basically he fought those Mongolian just because they disrupted his time alone with XLN, and not because he wanted to defend his country. And after he met XLN again after 16 years...they just disappeared and left jianghu forever. He just didn't care. If Yang Guo Feature In Battle Of Xiayang,Will Guo Jing And Huang Rong be saved? ---> I don't think so. On the last part of ROCH, GJ and HR got helped by Huang Yaoshi, Reverend Yideng, etc. but...they were all were leading some soldiers. HYS used his eight diagrams tactic to create some battle formations. Only martial art skill is not enough to be able to defeat massive soldiers. Is Wong Yat Shi,Chow Bat Tung,Ying Gu and South Emperor Duang Chi Hing get killed as well. --> I think they died in their own hometown. Xiangyang is located in northwestern Hubei Province. Huang Yaoshi was in Peach Blossom Island, should be in Zhejiang Province. While ZBT and Ying Gu, I don't know where they live. South Emperor Yideng was in Dali (yunnan province). Their distance to Xiangyang are relatively far away. And also at that time, communication was not advance. They might not get the news about the battle in Xiangyang in immediate time. The case where they all could meet in one place was actually could only happen in wuxia novel
|
|
|
Post by zh0angmey on May 13, 2019 22:50:49 GMT
I thought Yang Guo became more involve with Xiang Yang after the discussion he have with Ke Da Xia on about Yang Kang?
Yang Guo said they will never be able to invade at about 20:17 and beyond.....
Which version of TV drama series Condor Heroes do you think is more closer with the novel?
|
|
|
Post by Admin on May 14, 2019 4:23:47 GMT
I thought Yang Guo became more involve with Xiang Yang after the discussion he have with Ke Da Xia on about Yang Kang? Yang Guo said they will never be able to invade at about 20:17 and beyond..... Which version of TV drama series Condor Heroes do you think is more closer with the novel? Yang Guo said they will never be able to invade at about 20:17 and beyond.....--> what do you mean? sorry I don't get it. After talking to Ge Daxia - the blind of that 7 Freaks of Jiangnan, YG then realized that he misunderstood GJ and HR. Therefore he no longer had enmity to them. He also realized that his father was a traitor and not what he had always expected to be. He was willing to fight the Mongolian like what described in the book ROCH on the ending part, mainly because he wanted to save Guo Xiang - the daughter of GJ and HR. Again, the motives is not a pure patriotism. YG respected GJ and HR, and realizing that how much GJ loved him and treated him well although his father was such an evil toward GJ and HR made YG wanted to repay GJ and HR's kindness.
|
|
|
Post by zh0angmey on May 14, 2019 4:55:05 GMT
I was talking about episode 46 of Condor Heroes Yang Guo Andy version in 1983.
Please look at the episode 46 from 20:17 minute and beyond for understanding of what I'm trying to say about Yang Guo talking to Ke Da Xia on saying that they will never be able to invade which give me the impression that Yang Guo is very heroic for great Song.
If the video say it's not available, please look at YoTube.
I have only watch many TV drama series of the condor heroes, I have not read the novel yet.
|
|
|
Post by Admin on May 15, 2019 3:17:59 GMT
I was talking about episode 46 of Condor Heroes Yang Guo Andy version in 1983. Please look at the episode 46 from 20:17 minute and beyond for understanding of what I'm trying to say about Yang Guo talking to Ke Da Xia on saying that they will never be able to invade which give me the impression that Yang Guo is very heroic for great Song. I have only watch many TV drama series of the condor heroes, I have not read the novel yet. Ah, I see. Got it.
|
|