|
Post by galvatron prime on Nov 17, 2018 8:26:23 GMT
各版楊康,埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】 各版阿紫,埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】 各版阿朱,埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】 各版黃藥師,埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】 各版郭芙,埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】 各版郭襄,埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】 各版霍青桐,埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】 各版郭襄,埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】
|
|
|
Post by galvatron prime on Nov 17, 2018 8:32:19 GMT
各版郭靖,埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】 少女黃蓉,埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】 各版令狐沖,埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】 各版喬峰,埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】 各版中年黃蓉,美魔女埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】 各版段譽,埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】
|
|
|
Post by galvatron prime on Nov 17, 2018 8:45:58 GMT
各版楊過,埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】
【陳美濤口述金庸】八版小龍女 你最喜歡哪一個?
各版趙敏,埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】
各版張無忌,埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】
|
|
|
Post by galvatron prime on Nov 17, 2018 8:51:37 GMT
韋小寶,埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】
【新版金庸找不同】鹿鼎記【陳美濤口述金庸】
各版陳家洛,埋嚟睇埋嚟揀【陳美濤口述金庸】
各版東方不敗:是閹人還是絕色美人?【陳美濤口述金庸】
|
|
|
Post by siuyiu on Nov 18, 2018 2:59:37 GMT
interesting! i can only comment on the ones i have watched (or at least watched enough of): - young huang rong: michelle yim - middle-aged huang rong: susanna au yeung pui shan - huang yaoshi: kenneth tsang kong - zhou botong: chun wong - yang kang: michael miu kiu wai - yang guo: huang xiaoming - xiao feng: bryan leung kar yan - duan yu: kent tong chun yip - xiao long nu: carman lee yeuk tong - zhang wuji: lawrence ng kai wah - wei xiaobao: chan siu chun and none of these are surprises to those of you who've known me long enough. as for the other characters, don't really care/indifferent.
|
|
|
Post by caiyi on Nov 22, 2018 0:30:59 GMT
galvatron primeWhen did you discover Tomato's videos? I've been listening to her for quite sometime. I like her commentaries on the wuxia novels/series. Do you know she's an author herself?
|
|
|
Post by caiyi on Nov 22, 2018 0:35:52 GMT
- zhang wuji: lawrence ng kai wah I remember a lot of people criticise the casting of Lawrence as ZWJ because of his age. Why did you choose him as the best ZWJ? Is his portrayal most faithful to the book? I do remember Lawrence said before that his favourite Jin Yong's novel is HSDS because that's the first JY novel he read.
|
|
|
Post by siuyiu on Nov 22, 2018 0:57:16 GMT
- zhang wuji: lawrence ng kai wah I remember a lot of people criticise the casting of Lawrence as ZWJ because of his age. Why did you choose him as the best ZWJ? Is his portrayal most faithful to the book? I do remember Lawrence said before that his favourite Jin Yong's novel is HSDS because that's the first JY novel he read. i agree that he was too old compared to ZWJ's age, but he did a good job--he was able to show the vulnerability and introvertness of the character that neither adam nor tony managed to convey. so, despite the controversy of age, his was a more accurate portrayal.
|
|
|
Post by Admin on Nov 29, 2018 3:43:17 GMT
[/video][/quote] Yang Kang : my favorite : Michael Miu Kiu Wai (y) none can beat him. He got the handsome look, cool, noble, but also dangerous cunning look sometimes.
|
|
|
Post by Admin on Nov 29, 2018 3:47:31 GMT
A Zi of DGSD: 1. The first one - from DGSD 1983 2. Chen Hao from DGSD 2003
|
|
|
Post by galvatron prime on Nov 30, 2018 1:19:15 GMT
galvatron prime When did you discover Tomato's videos? I've been listening to her for quite sometime. I like her commentaries on the wuxia novels/series. Do you know she's an author herself? @caiyi I discover her video when I read the death of Jinyong news up next on YouTube. I don't know she was author.
|
|
|
Post by galvatron prime on Nov 30, 2018 1:23:22 GMT
interesting! i can only comment on the ones i have watched (or at least watched enough of): - young huang rong: michelle yim - middle-aged huang rong: susanna au yeung pui shan - huang yaoshi: kenneth tsang kong - zhou botong: chun wong - yang kang: michael miu kiu wai - yang guo: huang xiaoming - xiao feng: bryan leung kar yan - duan yu: kent tong chun yip - xiao long nu: carman lee yeuk tong - zhang wuji: lawrence ng kai wah - wei xiaobao: chan siu chun and none of these are surprises to those of you who've known me long enough. as for the other characters, don't really care/indifferent. @suiyiu You also vote and said Jason Bai Piu as the best Go Jing in LOCH in old Wuxia society poll ,am I right?
|
|
|
Post by siuyiu on Nov 30, 2018 2:43:08 GMT
@galvatron i probably did--don't remember! i think both he and wong yat wah did decent portrayals.
|
|
|
Post by Admin on Nov 30, 2018 3:01:57 GMT
For Wei Xiaobao : Tony Leung. I really hate the HXM version of WXB. How come Wei Xiaobao was more handsome than Kangxi? That's such an insult! Tony Leung and Andy Lau are the best DoMD couple of WXB and Kangxi
|
|
|
Post by Admin on Nov 30, 2018 3:08:33 GMT
各版東方不敗:是閹人還是絕色美人?【陳美濤口述金庸】 Dongfang Bubai : the 2001 version. I also like Brigite Lin version, but the 2001 is the best.
|
|